An Analysis of Building Collapse in Nigeria (1971-2016): Challenges for Stakeholders

  • F. C. Omenihu Department of Civil and Water Resources Engineering University of Maiduguri - Nigeria
  • L. O. Onundi Department of Civil and Water Resources Engineering University of Maiduguri - Nigeria
  • M. A. Alkali Department of Civil and Water Resources Engineering University of Maiduguri - Nigeria
Keywords: COREN, Nigeria, building codes and collapses

Abstract

The study investigated the analysis of collapsed buildings in Nigeria between1971 and 2016 and the challenges for the stakeholders. It examined the causes of some of the reported cases of building collapse and actions taken by the professional bodies, current building laws and the factors preventing the compliance with requirements of the Nigerian Building Codes (NBC 2006). The two methods used for data collection were primary and secondary approaches. The results show that the leading causes of building collapse within the period were structural failures (24.9%), substandard materials (13.2%) and poor workmanship (12.2%), faulty design (8.8%), use of quacks (7.3%) and inappropriate foundation (6.8%). It also noted though that, factors such as approval, design, geotechnical and regulation violations or excessive loading and carelessness ranged between (2.4 to 4.4%) individually; their harmful influences might lead to collapse of a major project even when under construction. Cities with most cases of collapse were Lagos (83), FCT Abuja (18), Rivers (13) and Oyo (14) and casualty rates recorded were Lagos (702), FCT Abuja (110), Rivers (178) and Oyo (127) which increased progressively over the years. The categories of buildings and their occurrences were 60% for private, 26% corporate and 14% public buildings. Therefore, the professional bodies and Standard Organization of Nigeria (SON) are to create awareness on the evils and risk involved in the use of Quacks. For a complete solution to be achieved, adequate number of functional laboratories, equipment and machinery must be provided nationwide. Collapsed building prevention and investigation units are to be created in the project approval Departments of the Federal, State and Local Government levels. To prevent errors, before approval of all three-storey buildings and above, a committee of professionals is to confirm the correctness of such designs, instead of limiting the design responsibilities to one consultancy firm.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Afolani, J.A and Taiwo, A.A. (2011).“Incessant building collapse”: a case study of Hotel in Akure, Nigeria. Published in Journal of Building Appraisal. Pp. 241-248

Agence, F.P. (2016). ‘Construction Company Bladed After Lagos Building Collapse Kills 34’.Retrieved on 24th March 2016 through the Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. https://en.m.w.

Ali, K. (2015).“COREN President Assessing School Building Collapse in Jos”. Retrieved from the netthroughwww.dailytrust.com.ng/news/general/corenassessing-collapse president/110822.html on Saturday,March 05, 2016.

APEC (2013). “Building Codes, Regulations and Standards; Minimum, Mandatory and Green” NathanAssociates Inc. Reviewed by United States Agency for International Development (USAID). APEC#213CT01.8.

Augustine Ike, C. (2012).“Case Histories of Building Collapses in Nigeria”. Published at NBRRI Proceedings of National Technical Workshop on Building Collapse in Nigeria, Pp. 41-57

Ede Nkem, A. (2010).“Building Collapse in Nigeria-The Trend of casualties in the last decade (2000-2010)”. Retrieved from International Journal of Civil Engineering IJCEE IJEN. Department of Engineering, Covenant University, Ota, Ogun State, 10(16).

Ejeh, S. P. (2011). “Building collapse Phenomenon in Nigeria: the role of NBRRI”. Published at NBRRIProceedings of Stakeholders’ Forum Pp. 67-77.

Federal Fire Service (2010). Lagos and Lagos State Fire Service, Ikeja. Her Majesty’s Stationery Office, (2004). “The Building Regulations 2000” — Approved

Document A: Structure. A3— Disproportionate Collapse. Office of the Deputy Prime Minister (ODPM)..2004 edition. ICBO (1997). “Codes and Related Publications, Uniform Housing Code”. International Conference of Building Officials, ISSN 0501-1213, ISBN 1-884590-82-9, Whittier, Califonia.

Michael Ajufoh, O. Gumau, W. A and Yaktor Joshua Inusa, 2014. “Curbing the menace of building collapse in Nigeria” Retrieved on the 6th of September, 2014 from the net through www.ilns.pl Nairaland Forum (2016). ‘Building Collapses in Mile 12 Lagos’. Retrieved from the net on 24th March 2016 through www.nairaland.com.

National Building Code of Practice NCP(1973). “Structural Use of Concrete”. Retrieved from the net on 11th March 2016 through https://www.scribd.com/.../Nigeria-Nation…

National Building Codes NBC (2006). “Federal Republic of Nigeria Building Codes of Practice”. 1st Edition. Lexis Nexis Butterworths. South Africa.

NBRRI (2011). “Technical Report on the collapse of a 2-storey Building at Mararaba” (Near Abuja). NBRRIReport No. 22 NBRRI Newsletter vol. 1, March, (2012). Collapse of 2-storey building at 45th, 1st Avenue Gwarimpa Estate, Abuja

NBRRI newsletter, 2008. “Collapse of a 1-storey commercial building under construction at Apo Mechanic Village, Abuja”, 1(8):20

NBRRI (2011). “Technical Report No. 23-Technical report on the collapse at Adenubi Close”, Ikeja, LagosState NBRRI Comments (2011). “Collapse of a six storey building” at No. 11 Aderibigbe Street, Maryland-Lagos

NBRRI (2012). “Analyses of the collapse of a two-storey building at Kubwa Extension III”. NBRRI Report No. 29, Abuja.

NBRRI (2012). “Curbing the incidences of building collapse in Nigeria”. NBRRI Proceedings of National Technical Workshop on Building Collapse in Nigeria. NBRRI Report No. 29, Abuja.

NBRRI (2012). “Federal Government Committed to Enforcement of Building Code”. NBRRI Newsletter 1(7).

NBRRI (2012). “NBRRI Organizes Training for Contractors”. NBRRI Newsletter 1(9) NBRRI Newsletter vol. 1, March, 2012.NBRRI Leads Investigation into Gwarimpa Building Collapse Pp.11

News 24 (2006).“Collapse of Three-storey Building in Lagos”. An online newspaper published by News 24 and Retrieved on the 6th of September, 2014 from the net through http://www.news24.com/news24/Africa/news/0,2 111447_197096.

News 24 (2006). “Collapse of Three-storey residential building at Lokoja, Kogi State”. An online Newspaper published by news 24 and Retrieved on the 23rd of July, 2014 from the net through http://www.news24.com/news24/Africa/news/o,2- 11-1447_186732.

Nigerian Tribune, (2008).“Collapse of a 4-storey shopping centre at Utako District – Abuja”, Nigerian Tribune, Tuesday 12th August, 2008.

Nistructe.org, (1990). “Collapse at Sague Comprehensive Primary and Secondary School, Port-Harcourt”.Retrieved on the 15th of November, 2013 from the net through http://www.nistructe.org/publications_details.php siteid=3&resolut.

Opara, P. (2006).“Building Collapse in Lagos State”: Journal of Technology and Education in Nigeria11(1):58-65. Premium Times ( 2015). ‘3-Storey Building Collapse in Lagos, 4 Rescued’. Retrieve from the net on 24th March, 2016, through http://www.premiumtimesng.com./..../191881-3. Proceedings of National Technical Workshop on Building collapse in Nigeria (2012). Curbing the incidence of building collapse in Nigeria

Proceedings of NBRRI (2011). Stakeholders Forum-Bridging the gap between Building and Road Research & stakeholders, NBRRI, Abuja

Tell Magazine, 16th January (1997). Culled from S.O. Izumo, “The Provision of Housing and Management in Nigeria”, Pp. 20.

The Lagos State Urban and Regional Planning and Development Law (2010). “Lagos Amends State Urban, Regional Planning, Development Law”. The Gazelle News. Retrieved from the net on 31st March, 2016 through www.thegazellenews.com/..../ Lagos-amend.

The United Kingdom Building Act (1984) as Amended Dec.(2006). The Building Regulations and The (Approved Inspectors etc.) Regulation 2000. Circular 05/2006, Department for Communities and Local Government Eland House,

Bressenden Place, London SWIE 5DU. The Punch, (2009).“Collapse of Twostorey building at Lagos” Monday, June 29, 17(20):42-44

Published
2016-06-27
How to Cite
F. C. Omenihu, L. O. Onundi, & M. A. Alkali. (2016). An Analysis of Building Collapse in Nigeria (1971-2016): Challenges for Stakeholders. Annals of Borno, 26(1), 113-140. Retrieved from http://journals.unimaid.edu.ng/index.php/annals_of_Borno/article/view/30